Beyond Today Daily

Books That Feed You: March of Folly

Well-written books have the ability to challenge our assumptions and give us a sense of history and understanding.

Transcript

[Darris McNeely] If you're like me, and I'm pretty sure you are, you've been bewildered and somewhat irritated by politics of recent years and the back and forth, and handling the COVID, and the economy, and other ideological matters that have just turned things upside down. After last year's election, I pulled a book off my shelf that I've had for more than three decades called "The March of Folly," written by a Pulitzer Prize-winning historian, Barbara Tuchman, years ago. Ms. Tuchman wrote a number of history books. And had you ever had her as a history teacher in college or high school, you would have liked history because she writes in a very colorful, engaging way. And every one of her books have stood the test of time and actually still speak to events today. This one, especially "The March of Folly: From Troy to Vietnam." What she does is to go through episodes in history that show how governments act against their own self-interest.

The cover on this particular edition shows the Trojans bringing that Greek horse in. And she poses the question, "What got into their minds to bring that horse through their gates in Troy?" Now she goes through other stories from history. She talks about the Renaissance Popes and how they lost control through corruption and greed. She talks about how actually the British lost the American colonies through policies that just were working against their interests. And even the United States, she concludes in her last part of the book, by its folly in Vietnam in the 1960s and into the early 1970s. "The March of Folly" still speaks to the problems of human governance, no matter who, or when, and where in history. And it brings up that particular problem. And I would recommend it as a book that is one that feeds you for a long time. It's like the Scripture in Ecclesiastes 12, that says about the books of which there are no end of making these books. But the ones that you want are the ones that have the well-driven nails, the ones that kind of were pounded in and hold together a structure, a sense of history, a sense of understanding. This is one of those books I would recommend for you, "The March of Folly."

Let me just conclude with a few sentences from the end of the book. After she surveys the stories that she does, she points to the ambition, the corruption, and the problems of coming to a wise government. And she says we should look for people of character. And obviously, that's what everyone has done throughout history, but it's rarely found. And she says while such virtues may in truth be in every man's powers, virtues like justice, and equity, and honesty, they have no less chance in our system than money and ruthless ambition to prevail at the ballot box. The problem she says, may be not so much a matter of educating people for government as educating the electorate, the people to recognize and reward integrity of character and reject that which is false. She says, "We can only muddle on as we have done in these same 3,000 or 4,000 years of human history through patches of brilliance and decline, great endeavor, and shadow.

Her conclusions in the book, I think echo many principles of the Bible. And it's one of those books again that I'd like to point out to our "Beyond Today" audience that feeds you for a long time. "The march of folly from Troy to Vietnam," Barbara Tuchman, worth putting on your summer reading list or you're reading list report anytime for that matter.

That's BT Daily. Join us next time.

Like what you see?

Create a free account to get more like this

Darris McNeely

Darris McNeely works at the United Church of God home office in Cincinnati, Ohio. He and his wife, Debbie, have served in the ministry for more than 43 years. They have two sons, who are both married, and four grandchildren. Darris is the Associate Media Producer for the Church. He also is a resident faculty member at the Ambassador Bible Center teaching Acts, Fundamentals of Belief and World News and Prophecy. He enjoys hunting, travel and reading and spending time with his grandchildren.

Related Media

The Continuous March of Folly

Studying the bible?

Sign up to add this to your study list.

Course Content

Human lust for power seems to be a prime cause of misgovernment within leaders—the will of one person to exert rule over others, no matter what form that may take.

"Know, my son, with how little wisdom the world is governed." With these words, a little-known Swedish chancellor during the strife of the Thirty Year's War of the 1600s, Count Axel Oxenstierna, effectively put forth a maxim that explains much of the crisis in today's world leadership.

And in the words of America's second president, John Adams, "While all other sciences have advanced, government is at a stand; little better practiced now than three or four thousand years ago."

I encountered these quotes while reading famed historian Barbara Tuchman's The March of Folly: From Troy to Vietnam, a masterfully insightful book written in 1984. Tuchman chronicled the folly of governments from the ancient world to more modern times.

Misgovernment, she wrote, is of four kinds. First is tyranny or oppression, of which history provides so many well-known examples. Second is excessive ambition. Among those cited is Germany's twice-attempted rule of Europe by a self-conceived master race. Third is incompetence or decadence. Czar Alexander II, last of Russia's Romanov dynasty, is a prime example. Finally she lists folly or perversity.

History is full of examples of each of these kinds of misgovernment. Common to all, it seems, is the unbridled lust for power that, once attained, can result in disastrous consequences that endures for generations. There is a principle from Scripture that confirms the long-lasting effects of doing wrong, both personally and collectively: "The Lord is longsuffering and abundant in mercy, forgiving iniquity and transgression; but He by no means clears the guilty, visiting the iniquity of the fathers on the children to the third and fourth generation" (Numbers 14:18).

Tuchman retells the biblical story of Rehoboam, son of Solomon, who succeeded his father in the 10th century B.C. to the throne of Israel, a nation composed of 12 tribes descended from the patriarch Jacob.

Rehoboam was determined to continue Solomon's heavy burden of taxation despite pleas from representatives of the people who sought relief and fairer treatment from government. His act of folly led to the threat of secession by the 10 northern tribes who gathered around the town of Shechem, the political center of the revolt. Rehoboam immediately traveled to Shechem to confront the rebellion. When met by a delegation and after hearing their demands for a new wage and work contract, he asked for three days to consult with advisors and return with an answer.

Rehoboam, young and energized with the sense of power and authority, heard two completely contrary sets of advice. His older counselors advised renegotiation of terms and to "speak good words to them." More good will would be gained, they said, and "they will be your servants forever" (1 Kings 12:7).

Rejecting this course, he turned to his younger advisors, men he had grown up with—of his own generation. Seeking the favor of the young king and falling into the habit of obsequious counselors to this day, they advised against any new contract provisions.

You can imagine some young speechwriter offering this slogan for which Rehoboam would be forever known: "Whereas my father put a heavy yoke on you, I will add to your yoke; my father chastised you with whips, but I will chastise you with scourges" (verse 11).

Upon hearing this speech, the northern 10 tribes instantly broke off talks and moved to form a separate nation, no longer tied to the royal house of David—the dynasty of rulers descended from David. "To your tents, O Israel! Now, see to your own house, O David!" became the rallying cry (verse 16).

All other attempts at reconciliation were rejected, and a new nation was formed. The tribes selected a man named Jeroboam to be king. He reigned for 22 years, and there was continual strife between him and Rehoboam the entire period. After a 200-year period of decline and religious apostasy, the 10-tribed nation of Israel was taken captive by the Assyrian Empire and disappeared into the mists of history, to emerge at length in a modern form.

The kingdom of Judah lived on, eventually overtaken by Babylon. The descendants of that nation are the Jewish people—some of whom now dwell in their ancient homeland under the flag of the state of Israel. Even today the land is not without conflict, as the Jewish state must contend with the claims of indigenous Arabs and the enmity of surrounding Arab nations, resentful of their presence, their prosperity and their heritage. The consequences of Rehoboam's folly has left its mark through almost 3,000 years of history.

Human lust for power seems to be a prime cause of misgovernment within leaders—the will of one person to exert rule over others, no matter what form that may take. If John Adams' insight about government is still true—and current events and trends make it evident it is—then we should not expect this world to dramatically change in that respect, no matter what any politician might promise. "Hope and change" is still an ephemeral vision.

Yet times will ultimately change. Isaiah foretold the coming of One who will bring that change—the greatest Leader who was ever born, of the lineage of David, who will soon return to this earth to rule:

"For unto us a Child is born, unto us a Son is given; and the government will be upon His shoulder. And His name will be called Wonderful, Counselor, Mighty God, Everlasting Father, Prince of Peace. Of the increase of His government and peace there will be no end, upon the throne of David and over His kingdom, to order it and establish it with judgment and justice from that time forward, even forever. The zeal of the Lord of hosts will perform this" (Isaiah 9:6-7)

Until then the burden is on each of us, with His help, to monitor our character, curb our ambition, avoid corruption and mature emotionally. Doing this will help us develop the character of a leader like Jesus Christ.

Darris McNeely works at the United Church of God home office in Cincinnati, Ohio. He and his wife, Debbie, have served in the ministry for more than 43 years. They have two sons, who are both married, and four grandchildren. Darris is the Associate Media Producer for the Church. He also is a resident faculty member at the Ambassador Bible Center teaching Acts, Fundamentals of Belief and World News and Prophecy. He enjoys hunting, travel and reading and spending time with his grandchildren.